Featured Post
Divorce During Menstruation
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Divorce during menstruation is sinful and against the Sunnah, but it is valid according to all four Sunni schools of law, including the Ḥanbalī madhhab.
- Explanation: It is not allowed to issue a ṭalāq to a woman while she is menstruating.
- Evidence:
- The Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) was informed that Ibn ʿUmar divorced his wife during her menstruation. The Prophet became upset and said: “Command him to take her back and keep her until she becomes pure (from menstruation), then menstruates again and becomes pure again. Then, if he wishes, he may divorce her while she is pure and not approached (for intercourse).”
— Sahih al-Bukhari & Sahih Muslim
- The Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) was informed that Ibn ʿUmar divorced his wife during her menstruation. The Prophet became upset and said: “Command him to take her back and keep her until she becomes pure (from menstruation), then menstruates again and becomes pure again. Then, if he wishes, he may divorce her while she is pure and not approached (for intercourse).”
- Reason: During menstruation, emotional and physical changes may impair judgment, and the ʿiddah (waiting period) cannot begin properly.
- Note: Though it is sinful, if such a divorce is pronounced, it still counts according to the majority of scholars (Ḥanafīs, Mālikīs, Shāfiʿīs, Hanbali), but the person is accountable for doing so improperly. The narration of Ibn ʿUmar shows the Prophet (ﷺ) ordered him to revoke the divorce but did not declare it invalid.
✅ Is Ṭalāq during menses valid?
Yes, all four Sunni madhāhib — Ḥanafī, Mālikī, Shāfiʿī, and Ḥanbalī — agree that:
Divorcing a woman during her menses is sinful and against the Sunnah, but it is still valid and counts as one ṭalāq.
This is the jumhūr (majority) view and is also the correct Ḥanbalī position as clarified in:
- Manrus al-Sabeel Sharh al-Dalil (Hanbali manual)
- Al-Mughni by Ibn Qudāmah – who explicitly states that although this form of divorce is innovative (ṭalāq bidʿī), it is still effective.
Why is there confusion?
Some contemporary preachers (and a minority of scholars in later generations) argue that ṭalāq during menses should be invalid, based on qiyās (analogy) and the Prophet’s disapproval. But this is a minority opinion not held by the classical Hanbali school.
In fact, Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn al-Qayyim did lean toward invalidity of ṭalāq during menses based on reasoning (not textual evidence). However, this was considered a shādh (irregular) opinion and not the official view of the Ḥanbalī madhhab.
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Categories of Topics
Categories of Topics
- Antarctica
- Anthropology
- Anthropomorphism
- Aqidah
- Arabian Peninsula
- Arabic Language
- Arabs
- Archaeology
- Artificial Intelligence
- Asia
- Astronomy
- Atheism
- Australia
- Bangladesh
- Barzakh
- Big Bang Theory
- Biography
- Biology
- Black Hole
- Budhism
- cardiac health
- Catholic Church
- Charity
- Chemistry
- China
- Christianity
- Civil Law
- Climate Change
- Commercial Law
- Continents
- Cosmology
- Criminal Law
- Crypto-Politics
- Cryptocurrency
- CSS
- CSS Essays
- CSS Exams
- CSS Syllabus
- Current Account Deficit
- Current Affairs
- Cyber
- Dajjal
- Daleel at-Talib
- Dan Gibson’s Theory
- Dark Energy
- Deepfake technology
- Deforestation
- Deism
- digital firewall
- Distinctive Aspects of Islam
- Divine Remembrance
- Dragons and Dinosaurs
- Earthquakes
- Eclipse
- Ecology
- Economy
- Education
- Egypt
- Eid-ul-Fitr
- Elon Musk
- Emotional Intelligence
- End Times
- Energy
- Energy Crisis
- Environment
- Eschatology
- Esfahan
- Europe
- Evolution
- Evolution of Stars
- Family Law
- Fasting
- Feminism
- Fiqh
- Food Law
- Funerals
- Galaxy
- Gaza
- General Knowledge
- Genes
- Genetics
- Genital Worship
- Genocide Convention
- Geography
- Geology
- Geopolitics
- Global Affairs
- Global Crisis
- Global Warming
- Globalization
- Golden Bird
- Gravity
- Hadith
- Hajj
- Hajj Rituals
- Halal and Haram
- Halal Food
- Hanafi
- Hanbali
- Hanbali Aqidah
- Hanbali Madhab
- Hashimi Fiqh
- Hayy ibn Yaqzan
- health
- Heer Ranjha
- Highest Mountains
- Hijab
- Hindu Mythology
- History
- Holography
- Holy Scriptures
- Homosexuality
- Human
- Human Rights
- Ibn Sina’
- Ibn Taymiyyah
- Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal R.A
- Imam Al-Mahdi
- Imam Ali
- Impact on Society
- India
- Indonesia
- International Affairs
- International Law
- International Relations
- Iran
- Iran's Economy
- Islam
- Islamic Beliefs
- Islamic Civilization
- Islamic eschatology
- Islamic Festivals
- Islamic Golden Age
- Islamic History
- Islamic Laws
- islamic medicine
- Islamic Rituals
- Islamic Social System
- Islamic values
- Islamic worship
- Islamophobia
- Jesus
- Jewish eschatology
- Kabbalah
- Karbala
- Kings of Egypt
- Languages
- Largest Deserts
- Largest Lakes
- Leadership Skills
- LGBT Pride
- Lithium
- litrature
- Longest Rivers
- Lunar Cataclysm
- Makkah
- Maliki
- Mathematical Cartography
- Mathematics
- Microplastic
- Milky Way
- Modern World
- Music
- Muslim Cosmology
- Muslim History
- Muslim Parenting
- Muslim Ummah
- Mysterious sagas
- Neuralink
- Neurochemistry
- Neurology
- Neuroscience
- North America
- Oceans
- Organic Evolution
- PAF
- Pakistan
- Pakistan Affairs
- Pakistan’s Constitution
- Palestine
- Pedagogy
- Petroleum Warehouses
- Philosophy
- Phsycology
- Physics
- Political Science
- Politics
- Populism
- Pornography
- Poverty
- Pragmatic Theory of Truth
- Prophet Adam
- Prophet Ibrahim
- Prophet Muhammad (PBUH)
- Prophet Yousuf (AS)
- Prophethood
- Psychology
- Public Administration
- Punjab Government
- Quantum Computing
- Quantum Physics
- Qur'an
- Quran
- Rape
- Red Heifer
- Robointelligence
- Sahabah
- Salah
- Saudi Arabia
- Sawm
- Science
- Seerah
- SeismoAlert
- Seismology
- Self-Purification
- Shafi'ee
- Shariah
- Shaytan
- slamic morality
- Slavery
- Smoking
- Social Media
- Solar Eclipse
- Solar System
- South America
- Space
- Space Solar
- Spiritual Impact of Hajj
- Spiritual Impacts
- Sunnah
- SWOT Analysis
- Tafsir
- Taghut
- Taqdir
- Tawassul
- Tawhid
- Tawssul
- Tazkiyah
- Technology
- Technonlogy
- Terrorism
- testing
- The Earth
- The Gays of Gomorrah
- The Hebrew Hajirah
- The James Webb Space Telescope
- The Messiah
- The solar cycle
- The Structure of Ka’abah
- The Sun
- The Universe
- Time Travelling
- Trading
- Transparency International (TI)
- Travelling
- Truth
- Tsunami
- Turkestan
- Turkey
- U.S.-Saudi petrodollar pact
- Umrah
- Unemployment
- United Nations Organization
- Universal Hijri Calendar
- Urdu
- Usul
- Usul al-Fiqh
- Volcanic erruption
- Wahhabism
- War
- Waris Shah
- Waterfalls
- Weather Forecasting
- West
- Wildlife
- Wisdom
- Ya’juj and Ma’juj
- Zakat
- Zakat al-Fitr
- Zamzam Well
- Zionism